This completely compostable bag is I think the best I've ever used. First of all, there was never a time that I had an accidental finger poke through the bag from it being too flimsy. I ordered the standard size and they were plenty big for large messes (my German Shepherd) or small ones (the cat box). The main point that really impressed me was that I was able to easily tie and toss the bag with no problem and there was absolutely NO residual smell when I used the bags! That's worth 5 ✨ stars right there! I definitely recommend this product.