as first, I have long thick natural eyelashes so I dont need those volluminating ,water proof heavy mascaras.I just need something what wont smudge, will give my eylash shine and some nice natural boost. It goes off easily, its stays on, doesnt heart my eyes.Think I finally found really good mascara.And believe me, Im really obssesed with organic stuff, I will try all, from expensive to cheap. EWG best results, like body shop ones for years and I dont like them. Its just great